Skip to main content

Mobile measurements: Audits to verify location data

In recent years, the PTSS, the Zurich Cantonal Police and the three mobile network operators (Swisscom, Sunrise and Salt) have carried out several joint audits. The aim of these was to verify the integrity and reliability of the data provided by entities that are obliged to cooperate. At the PTSS’s request, the surveillance test drives required for the audits will be conducted regularly in future. An interview with Stefan Schär from the PTSS and René Odermatt from the Zurich Cantonal Police reveals more.

At the PTSS offices, there is a department with an impressive collection of mobile devices. The Compliance and Supervision Team is home to an inconspicuous grey metal cabinet containing a wide variety of smartphones, tablets and smartwatches ‒ from older models to the latest Apple and Samsung devices. These are used to carry out tests to ensure that the surveillance measures deliver what they are supposed to: the right data. The PTSS conducted around 76 test surveillances in 2024 to identify any problems in advance. Most of these tests take place on the PTSS’s premises, however, which means they are limited in some ways.

For every internet or call connection, mobile phone providers log the location of the mobile phone masts involved in the communication. As required by law, the telecommunications service providers (TSPs) send this location information to the PTSS for surveillance purposes. When verifying the accuracy of the information, the Compliance and Supervision Team always uses the same mobile phone mast as the reference point for stationary tests. This approach works well when checking the format of the data that is sent. However, it will not detect any inconsistencies relating to mobile surveillance targets. But now let’s take a look at the canton of Zurich, where a cantonal police car is driving through a rural area in the lowlands. Behind the driver are mobile communication measuring devices, laptops, screens full of technical code, maps and time displays. The cantonal police officers run through several scenarios: calls, streaming, messenger services and web browsing. They drive systematically through cities and towns, as well as through rural areas with poor or no reception. All of this is designed to help verify location detection during surveillance. The PTSS has shared the test scenarios it uses for these test trips and, working with the Zurich Cantonal Police, has determined additional test options to be used in a mobile environment. The Zurich Cantonal Police provides its expertise and the measuring systems required for the full audit, while the PTSS coordinates the tests with the TSPs. The Zurich Cantonal Police will continue to carry out this audit periodically in the future, in close cooperation with the PTSS. Stefan Schär from the PTSS’s Compliance and Supervision Team and René Odermatt, Mobile Forensics Expert at the Zurich Cantonal Police, explain all in this interview.

Interview with René Odermatt and Stefan Schär

What is your background and what are your duties at the PTSS/the cantonal police?

Schär: Shortly after finishing my apprenticeship, I specialised in telecommunications systems. Later, I completed two master’s degrees in IT and digital forensics. As a compliance specialist at the PTSS, I am responsible for ensuring the integrity and completeness of the data in our surveillance system (telecommunications surveillance processing system). I’m quite a fastidious person, and I can put that quality to good use here!

Odermatt: I worked in the mobile network planning and optimisation private sector for 15 years, and I have now been an expert in mobile forensics at the Zurich Cantonal Police for over ten years. We use scientific methods to analyse communication data from mobile networks. Our daily work includes answering questions such as whether a mobile phone was at a specific location.

How did this collaboration come about?

Schär: Our collaboration emerged almost naturally. The PTSS operates the telecommunications surveillance processing system and manages the test devices. The Zurich Cantonal Police has the equipment we need to complement our own. We are also in close contact with TSPs in our daily work, so we act as a crucial link between them and the police.

Odermatt: Exactly. We’ve been helping with mobile phone tracking throughout Switzerland for ten years. For example, we assist with missing person searches. The equipment needed for this, such as the measuring systems used in our audits, requires a significant investment – not only financially, but also in terms of acquiring expertise. Our reports are based on historical surveillance data. This means that the data from the test trips is particularly valuable because it supplements the historical data.

Can you briefly explain how your latest test trips went?

Schär: I was responsible for central coordination of the work between the Zurich Cantonal Police, the TSPs and the PTSS. This included distributing information and preparing the upcoming audits, activating surveillance of the test devices, using raw data to analyse the problems we identified, and coordinating follow-up tests and checks to verify that the TSPs had rectified errors. We worked with the Zurich Cantonal Police to determine the test scenarios in advance.

Odermatt: We worked with the PTSS to design these scenarios and plan the surveillance test trips in a way that reflects participants’ normal mobile communication behaviour. This means travelling through urban and rural areas, including places with poor network coverage. We processed and verified the data supplied by the TSPs, comparing the time stamps and reported location information with the data collected during the test trips. We then forwarded any inconsistencies we identified to the PTSS for further investigation.

Schär: Problems or inconsistencies were reported to the TSPs as soon as they were identified. I should mention that our cooperation with the TSPs was good, too. They rectified all the problems we reported to them very quickly.

What is the purpose of these tests? Can’t they be run by the mobile network operators?

Schär: The aim of the tests is to verify and guarantee the integrity of the secondary data supplied by the TSPs. We focus in particular on the location data, which we compare with the recorded data from the vehicle. If we discover any discrepancies, they have to be analysed in detail. Centralised coordination and implementation is the only way to ensure that the tests are carried out uniformly and consistently. Every TSP would probably organise its tests in a slightly different way, so the results would not be fully comparable.

Odermatt: And apart from that, it takes a lot of expertise to identify the call scenarios in the data. In order to share our findings, we sent the final report to all law enforcement agencies.

What challenges do you think surveillance will face in the future? In relation to technology, for instance?

Odermatt: I think growing complexity is the biggest challenge. This can be overcome by close cooperation between the stakeholders involved, such as TSPs, the PTSS and law enforcement authorities.

Schär: There are a number of technical challenges associated with 5G, such as the significantly higher data rates that have to be processed and the concealment of subscriber identities by using temporary identifiers.

What did you particularly enjoy about the collaboration?

Schär: Our work together was friendly and cooperative. The main thing I appreciated was how quickly everyone responded to each other, including the TSPs.

Odermatt: Everybody communicated openly, and we had the support we needed at every level. During the debriefing, things that had not gone as well as they could have were discussed head-on and will be taken into account in the next audit. We all had the same goal in mind, and we were able to build on our experience from previous audits. As we’ve already mentioned, none of this can be achieved unless TSPs, the PTSS and law enforcement agencies work together.